Yes and no. I wish I could write the story of three amazing homebirths as they all of these women planned for one. Is not very good marketing is it? However, all of them got to have safe births with no unnecessary interventions and their birth plans were respected. I always like to reflect on whether we could have done things differently to preserve physiology but, without going into all the clinical details that explained what happened, I think everyone did their best.
For the first client a breech vaginal birth with deskilled attendants would have been more stressful and riskier than an elective section. We spend hours going over her options which included transferring to another hospital or having a homebirth inviting another second midwife with more breech experience. Everyone has different perceptions of risk and how much risk they’re willing to take.
For Beth’s client (second birth) safety was also important and they were happy that the emergency was dealt with swiftly, respectfully and that she still had some time in hospital to attempt vaginal birth. I don’t want to go over all the details of the birth and mum’s history out of respect to the parents and their journey, but I can say that in all my years as a midwife I have only transferred out a low risk setting (home or birth centre) for fetal heart concerns in a handful of times, all of them justified as something else was going on on the background (not due normal physiological changes in the heart rate on second stage).
Lastly, the third homebirth. Amy’s client felt respected in her choice not to be induced, not to have VEs, not to labour in the hospital and she preferred a CS as opposed to an instrumental birth. Amy advocated for her in hospital and the family was happy with the outcome.
All these pregnancies and births would have been very different on the NHS with lots of pressure and fear from professionals. They would have also been quite different if these women freebirthed but I trust that women (or their birth attendants) could have spotted the complications and sought help as I believe in women’s choice to freebirth when she is well educated and supported. However, attending these births knowing that we respected women’s plans and we did not cause the interventions but we rather spotted abnormalities and acted safely and respectfully, made me really appreciate the work we do as independent midwives. Because even us being there is an intervention on itself but at the end of the day it’s the birthing woman’s choice of how much surveillance she wants, what’s her threshold for transfer and how far she wants to push guidelines. This is why my antenatal appointments are at least 2h long and I invest at least 2 more hours at home afterwards curating curating for clients so they make true informed choices (reminiscences of my job as a lecturer and my years as a student at masters level!).
I have been out as an independent midwife for a year now and I love it. I love the challenges, the growth I’ve experienced, the relationships I’ve developed with my clients, the beautiful homebirths I have witnessed and even doing my own bookkeeping!
If you want to learn more about how I can support you as an independent midwife contact me below.